4-Star and Up Nursing Homes in Sarasota, Florida

Data source: CMS Provider Data (Provider Information, Survey Summary).

Last updated: 2026-01-15T19:25:30.654Z

Information is provided for general reference and is not medical or legal advice.

Top rated 4-star and up Special focus Recent surveys

Glenridge On Palmer Ranch INC.

★★★★★5

7333 SCOTLAND WAY 34238

Beds: 61 Avg residents/day: 47.5

Pines Of Sarasota

★★★★★5

1501 N ORANGE AVE 34236

Beds: 171 Avg residents/day: 190.0

Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center

★★★★★5

1959 N HONORE AVE 34235

Beds: 45 Avg residents/day: 37.1

Plymouth Harbor Incorporated

★★★★★5

700 JOHN RINGLING BLVD 34236

Beds: 56 Avg residents/day: 36.2

Sarasota Memorial Nursing & Rehabilitation Center

★★★★★5

5640 RAND BLVD 34238

Beds: 120 Avg residents/day: 99.8

Sunnyside Nursing Home

★★★★★5

5201 BAHIA VISTA STREET 34232

Beds: 60 Avg residents/day: 50.2

Life Care Center Of Sarasota

★★★★★5

8104 TUTTLE AVE 34243

Beds: 120 Avg residents/day: 110.3

Sarasota Point Rehabilitation Center

★★★★☆4

2600 COURTLAND STREET 34237

Beds: 120 Avg residents/day: 99.4

Guides for families

Understanding CMS ratings

How to read the overall, staffing, and inspection scores.

Inspections and deficiencies

What inspection dates and categories mean for comparison.

Questions to ask

A tour checklist tied to CMS data.